In September, 2017, Reclaim The Records made a Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) request for a copy of what is colloquially called the BIRLS File from the United States Department of Veterans Affairs. This is a Veterans Benefits Administration database that provides information on deceased individuals including name, birth and death dates, branch of service, and enlistment and release dates. This request was one of the first two FOIA requests our organization had ever made under the federal law, rather than a state-level FOI law such as a state Sunshine Law.
The request was originally rejected by the VA for privacy reasons, but after our attorney contacted the agency, they said they would be referring the issue on for further study in a different department, rather than closing the request. At this time, we do not yet have an estimated completion date for this FOIA request, and it remains open.
Our original request was filed through the MuckRock website:
To Whom It May Concern:
This is a request under the Freedom of Information Act.
I represent a 501(c)(3) non-profit organization called Reclaim The Records. We are an activist group of genealogists, historians, journalists, and open government advocates who acquire genealogical and archival data sets and images from government sources, often through the use of Freedom of Information laws. We then upload those records to the Internet, making them freely available to the public and returning them to the public domain.
We request a copy of the Beneficiary Identification Records Locator Subsystem (BIRLS) Death File, a very large database maintained by your agency. This data has already been made available to the public before, and it is currently online at at least two major commercial genealogy websites, Ancestry.com and Fold3.com. We are now requesting a copy for our organization, so that we may post it online for free public use.
We would also like to recommend that your agency upload a copy of the file to the federal government’s open data portal, data.gov.
Based on this scanned “Request for Records Disposition Authority” document, located at archives.gov…
…it seems that the BIRLS Death File has the VA Item Number 08-065 000, and a copy may have already been turned over to the National Archives and Records Administration (NARA).
We request that this file be turned over to us in database format, as it already exists in a database. We would like to receive it on a portable USB drive, and we are willing to pay the costs for purchasing that drive and for its insured and trackable domestic shipping, as well as any fees associated with fulfilling this request. Please inform us of all fees in advance of fulfilling our order.
Thank you for your consideration, and we look forward to your timely response within twenty business days, as the statute requires.
State or Vital Records Jurisdiction: Nationwide
Government Agency: United States Department of Veterans Affairs
Record Type: Death Records
Record Years: 1941-present (approximately)
Record Format: Actual records
Record Physical Format: Database
Number of Records (Estimated): 13,537,417